Charcoal vs Wood Smoker

We may receive compensation when you click on external links. Learn more

Charcoal vs Wood Smoker Comparison

Are you thinking of switching from charcoal to wood for your grill? You're not alone. Some people believe that wood is a healthier, more environmentally friendly option than charcoal. But is it really? So, Charcoal vs Wood? Let's take a look at the pros and cons of each fuel source.

Charcoal vs Wood | Which One is the Best for Your Grill?

In our ever-changing world, there are always new ways to do things. Take cooking for example. There are now so many different ways to cook food, each with its own benefits and drawbacks. In this blog post, we're going to explore the pros and cons of using lump charcoal vs wood to cook food. We'll help you decide which is the best option for you! So without further ado, let's get started!

What is charcoal?

Charcoal is a type of carbon that has been treated with oxygen to create an extremely porous material. This porosity makes it ideal for use as a fuel, as it allows air to flow through it easily and allows it to light quickly.

There are two types of charcoal: hardwood charcoal and briquettes. Hardwood charcoal is made from, you guessed it, hardwoods! The most common hardwoods used to make charcoal are oak, hickory, and maple. Briquettes are made from a mix of sawdust, coal, and other materials.


Charcoal vs Wood Smoker
Charcoal vs Wood Smoker

Hardwood charcoal is the better option if you're looking for a natural product. It's also generally more expensive than briquettes. Briquettes are a good option if you're looking for a more budget-friendly option.

What Is So Great About Charcoal?

  1. Charcoal is a more efficient fuel than wood because it produces greater heat and lasts longer.
  2. Charcoal is cleaner burning than wood.
  3. Charcoal does not produce smoke when it is burned.
  4. Charcoal is more consistent than wood because it doesn't vary in moisture or temperament.

What is wood?

Wood is, quite simply, the wood of a tree! It's an organic material that has been used as a fuel source for centuries. There are many different types of wood that can be used for grilling, but the most popular are hickory, mesquite, and oak.

Hardwood charcoal is made from hardwoods, so it stands to reason that wood would be a good option for grilling. And it is! Wood is a great alternative to charcoal, and it has some unique benefits.

For starters, the wood imparts a unique flavor to food that charcoal simply can't match. If you're looking for a smoky, grilled flavor, wood is the way to go.

What Is So Great About Wood?

  1. Wood is a renewable resource, so it's more environmentally friendly than charcoal.
  2. Wood imparts a unique flavor to food that charcoal simply can't match.

How to use charcoal for the best results

How To Use Charcoal For The Best Results

If you're using charcoal, there are a few things you can do to ensure the best results. Lighter fluid is a definite no-no.

First, make sure the coals are evenly distributed before you start cooking. This will help ensure that the food cooks evenly.

Second, be sure to preheat the grill before you start cooking. This will help to prevent sticking and ensure that the food cooks evenly.

Third, be sure to monitor the temperature of the grill. The temperature can fluctuate, so it's important to keep an eye on it.

Fourth, be sure to clean the grill after cooking. This will help to prevent rust and ensure that it's ready for next time.

Finally, be sure to have a spray bottle of water on hand. You can use this to extinguish any flames that may flare up during cooking.

How to use wood for the best results

How To Use Wood For The Best Results

If you're using wood, there are a few things you can do to ensure the best results.

First, find a good spot for your fire. You want to make sure that the wood is away from any combustible materials.

Second, be sure to preheat the grill before you start cooking. This will help to prevent sticking and ensure that the food cooks evenly.

Third, be sure to have a spray bottle of water on hand. You can use this to extinguish any flames that may flare up during cooking.

Fourth, be sure to clean the grill after cooking. This will help to prevent rust and ensure that it's ready for next time.

Finally,  be sure to soak the wood in water for at least an hour before you use it. This will help to prevent the fire from getting out of control.

Which one is right for you?

Let take a look at the pros and cons when compare the grilling with wood vs charcoal below:

Grilling with Charcoal


  • Easy to Control: You can control the heat of your oven to cook the meat evenly and avoid burning it.
  • Low Cost: You can buy a bag of charcoal briquettes for less than $20.


  • Extra Mess: Handling lump charcoal can be a messy endeavor.

Grilling with Wood


Flavor: You can choose the right type of wood to perfectly flavor your cooking.

  • Hickory wood is a type of wood that has a mild, smoky flavor.
  • Mesquite is a sweet-smelling wood that can be used for cooking meat.
  • Pecan is the best nut for low-and-slow cooking.
  • Applewood has a subtle sweetness that is best for high-fat meat, like pork.
  • Oak is popular for smoking beef and pork because it produces dense, powerful smoke.

No Additives: Wood is a natural material that doesn't contain any chemicals, making it safe to use for cooking.


  • Difficult to Master:  It can be difficult to control the heat when grilling with wood. You'll need to carefully monitor the fire to make sure it doesn't get out of control.
  • Slow to Heat: It can take longer than BBQing with charcoal, but the food will have more flavor.


1. Why do we use charcoal instead of wood?

Charcoal is used as a fuel because it burns hotter, cleaner, and more evenly than wood. Additionally, charcoal emits far less smoke than wood, making it a better choice for indoor cooking.

2. Is charcoal just wood?

Charcoal is wood that has been heated in the absence of oxygen, which causes it to produce more carbon. This is usually done by burning wood in a closed container, or by the use of special chemicals. The resulting product is denser and harder than regular wood, and it burns hotter and cleaner. 

3. Is charcoal pure carbon?

Yes, charcoal is pure carbon. It's made by heating wood or other organic matter in the absence of air, which prevents it from burning completely. The resulting material is mostly carbon, with some oxygen and other minerals. 

Because of its high carbon content, charcoal is an excellent source of fuel and is used in a variety of applications, including grilling, barbecuing, and even water filtration. In fact, activated charcoal (which has been treated to create small pores that increase its surface area) is often used in hospitals to treat patients who have ingested poisoning or overdosed on drugs. 

So if you're looking for a pure source of carbon, look no further than your backyard grill!

4. Is charcoal more efficient than wood?

When it comes to efficiency, charcoal is definitely more efficient than wood. This is because charcoal burns at a higher temperature than wood, meaning that it can convert more of the timber’s energy into heat. 

Of course, this also makes charcoal more dangerous to use, as the high temperatures make it easy for fires to get out of control. Nevertheless, if used responsibly, charcoal can be a great way to generate large amounts of heat quickly and efficiently.

5. Which lasts longer charcoal Vs wood Smoker?

Typically, charcoal lasts longer than wood when used for cooking. This is because charcoal is a more efficient fuel source and produces less ash. However, the exact length of time depends on the type of charcoal and wood you are using, as well as how you are using them. 

For example, if you are grilling with charcoal briquettes, they will last about 1-2 hours before needing to be replenished. On the other hand, if you are using lump charcoal, it will last for 3-4 hours. Hardwoods such as oak or hickory will also last longer than softer woods such as pine. 

It is important to note that how you use your charcoal or wood can also affect how long it lasts. If you build a hot fire, it will burn through fuel faster than a low, smoldering fire. Additionally, if you let the ashes build upon your charcoal, it will insulate the coals and make them burn more slowly. So if you want your fuel to last longer, be sure to keep the ashes clear.

6. Does wood smoke more than charcoal?

There is no simple answer to this question, as the amount of smoke produced by a wood fire or charcoal fire depends on a number of factors, including the type of wood or charcoal used, the way the fire is built, and the weather conditions.

However, in general, wood produces more smoke than charcoal. This is because wood contains more water than charcoal, and when the water vaporizes it turns into steam, which creates smoke.

7. Is cooking with charcoal healthy?

Is Cooking With Charcoal Healthy?

There is no definitively right or wrong answer to this question since it depends on a number of factors. For instance, if you are using high quality charcoal that has been properly incinerated, then it should be safe to cook with. However, if the charcoal is of lower quality or has not been completely incinerated, then there could be harmful chemicals present that could potentially leach into your food.

Another factor to consider is how you are cooking with charcoal. If you are simply grilling food over an open flame, then there is likely little risk involved. However, if you are cooking in an enclosed space (such as a grill smoker) and the charcoal is not properly vented, then there could be a buildup of carbon monoxide which could be harmful.

So, while there is no definitive answer to this question, it is important to use caution and common sense when cooking with charcoal. If you are unsure about the quality of the charcoal or how to properly ventilate your grill, it is best to err on the side of caution and avoid using it.

8. Can you smoke with just wood?

Yes. It is possible to smoke with just wood, but it's not the most efficient way to do it. Wood produces a lot of smoke, and it can be difficult to get a consistent heat level with just wood.

A better way to smoke with wood is to use a smoker box or smoker pouch. These devices allow you to place wood chips inside them, which then generate heat and smoke. This is a much more efficient way to smoke with wood, and it will produce better results than trying to do it without one of these devices.

9. Can I smoke meat with charcoal?

While you can technically smoke meat with charcoal, it's not the ideal way to go about it. For the best results, you'll want to use wood chips or chunks for smoking. Charcoal tends to produce a lot of heat, which can make it difficult to control the temperature of your smoker. This can lead to your meat being overcooked on the outside while still being raw on the inside.

If you're insistent on using charcoal, make sure to use a good quality charcoal briquette that has been seasoned properly. You'll also want to soak your wood chips in water for at least 30 minutes before putting them on the coals. This will help create more smoke and prevent them from burning up too quickly.

10. Can you grill with just wood chips?

Yes, you can certainly grill with just wood chips - and in fact, many people prefer to do so, as it imparts a more authentic smoky flavor to the food. Of course, you'll need to make sure that your grill is big enough to accommodate the number of wood chips you'll be using, and that you soak them in water for at least 30 minutes beforehand to prevent them from catching fire.

Other than that, just follow your usual grilling procedure and enjoy the unique flavor that wood-smoked food will impart!

11. Can you mix charcoal and wood chips?

It is possible to mix charcoal and wood chips, but it is not recommended. The charcoal will absorb the moisture from the wood chips and they will both start to smolder and produce smoke. This can be a dangerous combination, as the smoke may contain harmful toxins.

12. Is it better to grill with charcoal or gas?

It really depends on what you're looking for in terms of flavor and convenience. Charcoal grills definitely have that classic smoky flavor that many people love, but they can be a bit more work to get going and maintain.

Gas grills are much easier to use - you just turn them on and start cooking - but some people say they don't give food quite the same flavor as charcoal. Ultimately, it's up to you to decide which type of grill is best for your needs.

13. Should I use wood or charcoal in my smoker?

There are pros and cons to using both wood and charcoal in smokers. Wood is a natural fuel and gives off a great smokey flavor, while charcoal is less expensive and easier to use than wood. However, wood can be difficult to light, and when it starts to burn it produces a lot of sparks which can cause a fire.

Charcoal also produces more ash than wood, which can dirty your smoker. In the end, it really depends on your personal preferences and what you're looking for in terms of flavor.

14. What is the best fuel for smokers?

There is no easy answer when it comes to what's the best fuel for smokers. Cigarette smoke is packed with toxins and chemicals that can do serious damage to the body, so it's important to find a source of fuel that will help offset some of those harmful effects.

Some people find that a high-protein diet helps reduce cravings for cigarettes, while others find that eating plenty of fruits and vegetables helps boost their energy levels and overall health. Whatever you choose, make sure to avoid processed foods and sugary drinks, which can do more harm than good.

15. What is the healthiest way to grill?

There is a number of ways you can make grilling healthier, such as using leaner meats, vegetables, and fruits. You can also avoid processed foods, high-fat sauces, and marinades. But perhaps the best way to make grilling healthier is to simply remove the skin from your meat before cooking it.

This will help reduce the fat content and make your meal healthier overall. So grill away this summer – just be mindful of how you’re doing it!

16. What's better charcoal or briquettes?

What's Better Charcoal Or Briquettes?

There is no definitive answer to this question as it depends on personal preferences. Some people prefer charcoal because it burns hotter and produces less ash. Others prefer briquettes because they are easier to light and produce less smoke. Ultimately, it is up to the individual to decide which type of fuel is best for their needs.

17. What is the best wood to make charcoal?

The best wood to make charcoal is oak. It has a very high carbon content and burns slowly and evenly, making it an ideal fuel for charcoal production. Other types of hardwood, such as hickory or maple, also work well for charcoal production.

18. What wood should you not smoke with?

There are a few types of wood that you should not smoke with, as they can produce harmful toxins when burned. These include anything from pine to spruce to cedar. Any wood from the conifer family (including fir, hemlock, and juniper) is best avoided, as it can release harmful compounds like phenols and terpenes into the smoke.

These toxins can irritate the lungs and throat, and may even be carcinogenic. So save these woods for your next bonfire, and stick to hardwoods like oak or maple when smoking meat or fish.


So, which is better for your grill - charcoal or wood? The answer may surprise you!

If you're looking for a more environmentally friendly option, wood is the way to go. It's also a great choice if you're looking for a more natural flavor in your food. However, if you're looking for the easiest and most convenient option, charcoal is the way to go. It's also a great choice if you're looking for a more intense flavor in your food.

Whichever fuel source you choose, make sure to follow the instructions on how to use it properly. And most importantly, have fun grilling!


I love grilling and cooking. There’s nothing better than spending a weekend afternoon in the backyard, firing up the grill, and cooking up some delicious food for friends and family. I’m always experimenting with new recipes, and I’m pretty proud of my skills in the kitchen.

I’m also a bit of a smartass. I like to make people laugh, and I have a pretty sharp wit. So if you’re looking for someone to keep you entertained, you’ve found your man!

Leave a Comment